Poland
Following the peaceful fall of communist party rule, Poland transitioned from authoritarianism to weak democracy in 1989. Poland exhibits mid-range performance across all four categories of democracy in the Global State of Democracy framework, showing especially high performance in Basic Welfare, Freedom of Movement and Local Democracy. Poland has experienced significant declines in Representation, Credible Elections, Access to Justice, Judicial Independence and Absence of Corruption over the last five years. It performs in the bottom 25 per cent of the world with regard to Civic Engagement. After the transition from communism, Poland also developed a high-income economy with a level of diversification that is beneficial for income and growth.
Historical memory, rooted in the experiences of World War II and in decades as a satellite state of the Soviet Union, has left a traumatic legacy. This has often been weaponized by politicians, who use these memories to stir up nationalist sentiments. In more recent history, accession to the European Union (EU) in 2004 has sparked ongoing discussion around national versus European identity, with Poles feeling identifying at both levels but also feeling concern about the impact of EU membership on sovereignty. Support for EU membership amongst the public remains above 90 per cent, despite disputes with the EU over certain democratic milestones. A second significant development is the rapid economic liberalization that accompanied democratization in the 1990s, which brought inequality and pronounced regional disparities. This is reflected today in voting patterns, which are spatially divided between the western/northern areas of the country and the eastern/southern. Relatedly, an urban-rural cleavage divides the country, with poorer rural communities supporting economic paternalism and social conservatism. Social conservatism is largely present in the political landscape due to the lasting influence of the Catholic Church. Around 90 per cent of Poles identify as Catholic, a plurality believe in a degree of separation between Church and politics. This debate over secularity forms another cleavage in Polish society, as right-wing parties tend to align themselves to the Catholic Church, using religion to justify further restrictions on abortion rights and promote ‘family values’ at the expense of LGBTQIA+ community rights.
Poland performs in the high range in gender equality; recent positive developments include the amendment of a law on domestic violence, expanding protection measures for victims. However, the data also show gender equality experiencing significant declines over the past decade, which may be attributed to broader concerning developments, including restrictions on women’s access to abortion and the suppression of human rights and LGBTQIA+ activists.
Looking ahead, it will be important to watch the development of Poland’s relationship with the EU, especially in light of the war in Ukraine and a faltering relationship with Viktor Orbán’s Hungary. How the EU and Poland resolve differences over the Rule-of-Law Conditionality Regulation will have important impacts on the Rule of Law. It will also be critical to watch elections in 2023, the results of which will shape the country’s performance across the GSoD indicators.
Monthly Event Reports
July 2023 | Parliament approves amendments to Russian influence committee
The ruling Law and Justice (PiS) party pushed through amendments to controversial legislation passed in May to reduce the powers of the State Committee for the Examination of Russian influence on the internal security of Poland between 2007-2022. The changes were proposed by President Andrzej Duda and supplemented by the lower house, the Sejm. They were subsequently rejected in the opposition-held Senate, citing concerns that the Committee can be used to disadvantage the opposition creating an uneven playing field ahead of the upcoming autumn elections. The Sejm narrowly overturned the Senate’s veto (with 235 votes in favour, and 214 votes against). The amendments are intended to address domestic and international outcry over vulnerability of the body to politicization, for example by specifying that members of the Committee cannot be sitting MPs. Venice Commission experts issued an urgent opinion stating that the Committee, even with the proposed amendments, is not an appropriate approach to countering foreign influence, and lacks guarantees against political misuse.
June 2023 | European Commission launches infringement procedure over Russian interference law
The European Commission launched an infringement procedure against Poland for violations of EU law, following Poland’s adoption of legislation in May 2023 establishing a special committee that could block people found to be influenced by Russia from holding public office. The law was found to “unduly interfere with the democratic process” and violates the principle of democracy enshrined in the Treaty on the EU. The law was also found to conflict with EU data protection laws (lacking safeguards for the protection of sensitive personal data), as well as the principles of legality and non-retroactivity of sanctions, and the rights to effective judicial protection, established in the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights. Mobilising against the new law, hundreds of thousands of Poles protested in Warsaw against the ruling Law and Justice (PiS) party, with smaller protests across Poland.
May 2023 | President Duda approves contentious Russian interference law
President Andrzej Duda signed into law the creation of a new political commission to examine Russian influence on Polish public officials, which has been promulgated by the ruling Law and Justice (PiS) party as a national security measure. The opposition has expressed concerns that the law could be abused by PiS to silence critics and fear it is designed to target opposition leader Donald Tusk. The nine members of the new commission will be elected by the Parliament. The commission’s purview is backward-looking, covering the period 2007-2022, including the years when Tusk’s Civic Platform (PO), the main opposition party and PiS’s major challenger in the upcoming elections in Autumn, was in power. Legal experts have criticised parts of the law as potentially unconstitutional, and these provisions have been referred to the Constitutional Tribunal (widely seen as under PiS influence) for review.
March 2023 | Hate speech conviction given by court in a win for LGBTQIA+ rights
A district court in Gdańsk found Mariusz Dzierżawski, the head of a conservative foundation, guilty of defaming LGBTQIA+ people for the first time, sentencing him to one year of community service, and ordering him to pay a fine and to issue an apology. Dzierżawski’s organisation, Foundation Pro – Right to Life, has run a campaign linking the LGBTQIA+ community to sexual abuse of children, promoting this message using vans, banners, and slogans. It follows a February 2020 decision from a court in Wrocław that found the campaign to be “informative” and “educational”. Poland’s hate crime laws do not currently cover sexual orientation or gender identity, and the ruling represents an important step in condemning hate speech against the LGBTQIA+ community.
Explore past monthly event reports
GSoD Indices Data 2013-2022
Basic Information
Human Rights Treaties
State party
Signatory
No action
