Argentina - April 2025

On 3 April, the Argentine Senate rejected President Milei’s two nominees for the Supreme Court: federal judge Ariel Lijo and law professor Manuel García-Mansilla. This followed Milei’s controversial decision to bypass the Congress by appointing both nominees by presidential decree, arguing that the constitution granted him the authority to do so during a congressional recess. This action was widely criticized as an overreach of executive power and a threat to judicial independence. After the Senate’s rejection, García-Mansilla, who had already assumed his position, submitted his resignation to the executive. Lijo had not been allowed to assume his role, as the Supreme Court refused to accept his appointment while he remained on leave from his federal judgeship, insisting he first resign. He had therefore decided to wait for Senate confirmation. As a result, Argentina’s Supreme Court remains with only three of its five seats filled. Legal experts have praised the Senate’s decision as a necessary stand against what they see as one of the most serious threats to judicial independence in the country’s democratic era.

Sources: AP News, International IDEA, Chequeado (1), Chequeado (2), Infobae