The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly: Rethinking Election Monitoring

722
This publication is only available in electronic format
Published: 
1 December 2012
Language: 
English
Pages: 
19
Author(s): 
Judith Kelley

International election monitoring has become a prominent tool for promoting election integrity and democracy, but several factors raise questions about the validity and effectiveness of international election monitoring.

When organizations have to return to the same countries election after election, what are they accomplishing? When politicians continue to cheat in the presence of monitors, is the mission worthwhile? When more and more organizations join the practice without any uniform standards for assessing an election, and when different organizations sometimes disagree, how can outsiders know which organizations are reliable?

This discussion paper suggests some steps that regional organizations can take to streamline election monitoring and focus their efforts more effectively. Although it suggests some ideas for reforms, the goal is not necessarily for organization to adopt these particular suggestions, but for them to face the questions and discuss a variety of possible reforms.

Contents

A Few Facts About the Growth and Activities of Election Monitoring

Central Dilemmas and Questions

The Attention Dilemma

Recommendations

Closing Thoughts

References

Related Content

Mar
22
2019
Campaigning is very much happening along the streets of Bangkok. Image credit:  Adhy Aman, International IDEA

Campaigning is very much happening along the streets of Bangkok. Image credit:  Adhy Aman, International IDEA

Commentary
Feb
12
2019
From left to right: Siegfried Bracke, Andreas Norlén, Kristien Van Vaerenbergh, Jacques Brotchi, Yves Leterme.  Image credit: International IDEA

From left to right: Siegfried Bracke, Andreas Norlén, Kristien Van Vaerenbergh, Jacques Brotchi, Yves Leterme. Image credit: International IDEA

News Article
Feb
08
2019
Preliminary election results of the presidential election (3 February 2019) in El Salvador. Image Credit: Supreme Electoral Tribunal of El Salvador.

Preliminary election results of the presidential election (3 February 2019) in El Salvador. Image Credit: Supreme Electoral Tribunal of El Salvador.

News Article
Feb
01
2019
El Salvador will hold the first round of elections to elect a new president on 3 February, and on 10 March, the second round if necessary. Above, facilities of the system to capture and transmit the electoral results records. Image Credit: Supreme Electoral Tribunal of El Salvador.

El Salvador will hold the first round of elections to elect a new president on 3 February, and on 10 March, the second round if necessary. Above, facilities of the system to capture and transmit the electoral results records. Image Credit: Supreme Electoral Tribunal of El Salvador.

News Article