Constitutional Courts after the Arab Spring: Appointment mechanisms and relative judicial independence

4,148
This publication is only available in electronic format
Published: 
15 April 2014
Language: 
English
Pages: 
138
ISBN: 
978-91-87729-40-9 (Print)
Author(s): 
Sujit Choudhry, Katherine Glenn Bass
Co-Publisher(s): 
Center for Constitutional Transitions at NYU Law
Available Languages:

The Arab World is experiencing an unprecedented moment of constitutional transition. Many countries in the region are reforming their systems of constitutional judicial review as a way of signalling the government’s commitment to the rule of law. This includes establishing constitutional courts, a body with exclusive jurisdiction over constitutional judicial review.

This report investigates how constitutional court appointment-procedures can be designed to promote both judicial independence and judicial accountability to a democratically elected government. It analyses four models and examines how the models have been applied in six countries: Egypt, Germany, Iraq, Italy, South Africa and Turkey. The report also presents a comparison of the qualifications required for appointment to the constitutional court, and the rules for removing constitutional court judges.

The report is part of a series of on issues in constitutional design that have arisen in the Arab region published by the Center for Constitutional Transitions at New York University Law and the International IDEA. These reports are designed for use in support of constitution-building activities in the Arab world.

Contents

1. Introduction

2. Constitutional court appointments: MENA region challenges

3. Principles of constitutional design

4. Judicial appointments: design options

5. Judicial qualifications and removal procedures

6. Analysis of the June 2013 draft Constitution of Tunisia

7. Conclusion

References

Appendix: Selected constitutional and legal provisions on constitutional courts

Related Content

Feb
25
2022
Press Release
Feb
21
2022
Aftermath of Attack on Abyei, Ethiopia. Image credit: United Nations Photo is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0.

Aftermath of Attack on Abyei, Ethiopia. Image credit: United Nations Photo is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0.

Commentary
Oct
05
2021
In the picture, Sergio Bitar (board of IDEA International), Elisa Loncon (President of the Constitutional Convention), Jaime Bassa (Vicepresident of the Constitutional Convention), María Jaraquemada (Programme Officer of IDEA International) and Renata Retamal (Consultant and assistant of IDEA International).

Sergio Bitar (Board of Advisers, International IDEA), Elisa Loncon (President of the Constitutional Convention), Jaime Bassa (Vice President of the Constitutional Convention), María Jaraquemada (Programme Officer, International IDEA) and Renata Retamal (Consultant and assistant, International IDEA).

News Article