Assessing the Performance of the South African Constitution

2,163
This publication is only available in electronic format
Published: 
20 May 2016
Language: 
English
Pages: 
120
ISBN: 
978-91-7671-053-1 (Print)
Author(s): 
David Bilchitz, Daryl Glaser, Andrew Konstant, Linette Du Toit, Khomotso Moshikaro, Merle Werbeloff

The idea that the performance of a constitution can be evaluated is a relatively recent one.

Are there better or worse ways of drafting constitutions for the purposes of achieving desired outcomes? How are we to understand the interaction between particular provisions or elements of a constitution and the concrete realities that unfold after the moment of constitution drafting?

This report focuses on key tensions and stress points that have arisen in the past 20 years within the South African political community as a method of analysing some of the key goals of the Constitution and whether they have been met.

It draws on case law, reports by the government and non-governmental organizations, and other empirical data to assess the performance of the South African Constitution and offers a series of recommendations on potential changes to the Constitution that could help address its shortcomings.

This report is based on a longer study commissioned by International IDEA and prepared by the South African Institute for Advanced Constitutional, Public, Human Rights and International Law, a Centre of the University of Johannesburg. 

Contents

Acknowledgements

Abbreviations

Executive Summary

1. Introduction

2. Determining the internal goals of South Africa’s Constitution

3. Assessing the performance of South Africa’s Constitution

4. Conclusions and recommendations

References

Annex. Constitutional legitimacy: A survey of the Gauteng adult population

Related Content

Mar
18
2021
Image credit: International IDEA

Image credit: International IDEA 

Press Release
Jan
20
2021
Group work during community dialogue session organized by SUDO and supported by International IDEA on16 December 2020. North Darfur, Al Fashir. Image credit: International IDEA

Group work during community dialogue session organized by SUDO and supported by International IDEA on16 December 2020. North Darfur, Al Fashir. Image credit: International IDEA

Feature Story
Dec
11
2020
A Coherence Programme mentor talking to female Executive Members of Aurahi, rural municipality province. Credits of the image: International IDEA.

A Coherence Programme mentor talking to female Executive Members of Aurahi Rural Municipality, Province 2. Credits of the image: International IDEA.

News Article
Nov
11
2020
Image credit: International IDEA

Image credit: International IDEA

Press Release