What is plurilateralism, and can it deliver for democracy?
As the international order becomes more fragmented and consensus harder to achieve, plurilateralism is gaining ground as a way for countries to build ‘coalitions of purpose’ around shared interests, objectives or values. Such coalitions offer countries a flexible way to act together when broader agreement is difficult, while complementing rather than replacing multilateral institutions.
Why these coalitions are gaining ground
The growing interest in plurilateral cooperation reflects broader changes in the international environment.
Geopolitical competition, diverging national interests and different understandings of democracy and the international order are putting established forms of international cooperation under pressure, even as multilateral institutions remain indispensable.
Against this background, these coalitions of purpose have become more prominent. They bring together a defined group of countries around a shared interest, objective or set of values and may take the form of standing alliances, informal dialogue groups, ad hoc coalitions or partnerships focused on a particular policy challenge.
Their attraction lies in their flexibility. A smaller group of partners may be able to define commitments more clearly, mobilize resources more quickly and move from discussion to implementation. Plurilateral cooperation can also help countries build strategic capacity and amplify their influence by acting collectively.
However, the rise of plurilateral initiatives also raises difficult questions. Coalitions formed around common values can become exclusive clubs. Cooperation among a limited group of countries can be perceived as bloc politics rather than principled diplomacy. A proliferation of overlapping initiatives can also make it difficult for foreign ministries to determine which forums to prioritize and how to maintain coherent positions across them.
Values-based realism in a changing international order
These developments form part of a wider debate about how democracies should navigate a more competitive international environment. The concept of ‘values based realism’, associated with Finnish President Alexander Stubb and subsequently echoed by Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney, offers one way of thinking about this challenge.
Values-based realism rests on two elements. The first is a commitment to principles such as democracy, human rights, freedom, the rule of law, the protection of minorities and international institutions. The second is a recognition that governments must operate in a world where not all partners share these principles, and where cooperation and compromise may still be necessary to address common challenges.
Applied to plurilateralism, this means remaining clear about the values that guide international engagement while being pragmatic about where progress can be made and with whom. It is not an argument for abandoning multilateralism or engaging only with like-minded partners. Rather, it points to a layered approach in which countries work through different coalitions according to the issue at hand, while continuing to invest in international institutions and broader cooperation.
For democratic middle powers in particular, flexible coalitions can provide a way to pool influence, share capabilities and protect space for independent action in an international system increasingly shaped by great-power competition.
A ‘big tent’ or a focused coalition?
A central discussion about plurilateralism is the tension between inclusion and effectiveness.
This discussion highlights the importance of a broad ‘big tent’ for democracy cooperation. Democracy support is still sometimes perceived as an agenda promoted by a small group of established actors, particularly when it is presented in ways that appear to lecture rather than engage. This can weaken trust and reinforce divisions between regions.
A more credible approach would recognize that democracies exist across a spectrum and that their direction of travel may be as important as comparisons against a single standard. It would create greater space for democratic actors from different regions and acknowledge the experience, innovation and political leadership emerging from the Global South.
At the same time, inclusiveness cannot come at the expense of purpose. Coalitions need enough common ground to turn commitments into action. In some cases, a more focused approach can help maintain ambition and achieve concrete results.
The choice is therefore not simply between an exclusive club and an unrestricted coalition. The challenge is to build initiatives that are broad enough to carry legitimacy but sufficiently focused to act.
Credibility depends on delivery
Shared values and political declarations are not enough. Effective plurilateral cooperation requires clear objectives, adequate resources, institutional ownership and mechanisms through which progress can be assessed. Countries should be able to explain the specific challenge a coalition addresses, the result it seeks to achieve and why a smaller format adds value.
Some of the existing plurilateral initiatives show the value of combining clear commitments with action, peer learning and accountability. Their strength lies not only in who participates, but also in their ability to turn cooperation into concrete results.
Plurilateralism will therefore be judged not by how many coalitions are created, but by whether they make democratic cooperation more effective and improve people’s lives.
Connecting coalitions rather than creating new silos
This debate cautions against continuously creating new initiatives. Before launching another plurilateral initiative, governments should examine whether an existing platform, network or community can serve the same purpose.
This is partly a question of efficiency. New initiatives require staff, political attention and financial resources. They may also duplicate existing work or weaken forums that already have expertise and relationships in place.
It is equally a question of coordination within government. Ministries of Foreign Affairs (MFAs) need to identify which departments and agencies already lead on the relevant issue, connect foreign policy priorities with existing expertise, and establish clear institutional ownership. Ensuring continuity helps maintain momentum, particularly when responsibilities change hands.
Reinforcing, not replacing, multilateralism
Plurilateralism should not be presented as an alternative to multilateralism. Universal institutions continue to provide legitimacy, common rules and spaces in which countries with different political systems can address shared challenges.
Smaller coalitions can nevertheless complement these institutions. They can test new approaches, build agreement among a group of committed partners and demonstrate what practical cooperation can achieve. Successful ideas may subsequently inform wider multilateral processes.
The risk arises when smaller coalitions deepen fragmentation, reproduce existing geopolitical divisions or exclude countries whose participation is necessary for meaningful progress. Their value should therefore be assessed in terms of the gap they address and the contribution they make to the wider international system.
Looking ahead
Plurilateralism can help democracies navigate a period of geopolitical fragmentation and stalled consensus, but it is not an end in itself.
Effective plurilateral initiatives require a clear purpose, committed participants and a credible path from dialogue to implementation. They must be sufficiently focused to deliver, but open enough to draw on diverse democratic experiences and avoid becoming clubs of the usual actors. They also need adequate resources, institutional continuity and a clear relationship with existing multilateral structures.
For MFAs, the task is both strategic and practical: deciding where plurilateral engagement adds value, coordinating participation across government, and ensuring that cooperation contributes to coherent foreign policy objectives.
Ultimately, the credibility of plurilateralism will depend on whether it helps democracies act together more effectively. The most promising plurilateral initiatives will need to combine shared principles with practical action, remain open and inclusive, and contribute to an international system that responds effectively to people’s needs.
These are some reflections draw on the fifth #DemoTalks exchange among representatives of Ministries of Foreign Affairs (MFAs), convened by International IDEA, the Open Government Partnership and the Community of Democracies.