What are the key reasons for or against using open source systems?

Philippines

Philippines

Answer
Security
Source

2011 Carter Center Final LimitedElection Observation Report

Public Concerns Regarding theAutomated Election System

Software Architecture

A lack of transparency inherentin the use of voting technologies, in which there is no physical, observablevote count, was also a source of concern. Some critics of the AES called for asystem based entirely on open- source software and wanted automation limited tothe process of vote transmission to canvassing centers, with voting andcounting to be carried out using traditional, manual methods. A manual vote andcount coupled with automated transmission, they contended, would be morecost-effective and would promote public confi- dence in the election; however,efforts to use electoral technologies to decrease the time necessary to conductresults aggregation would potentially be undermined by retaining a manualcount.

Source: https://www.cartercenter.org/resources/pdfs/news/peace_publications/election_reports/philippines-may%202010-elections-finalrpt.pdf

Comment
Some critics of the Automated Election System called for a system based entirely on open-source software and wanted automation limited to the process of vote transmission to canvassing centers, with voting and counting to be carried out using traditional, manual methods. 
Close tooltip